Erik Menéndez Slams Ryan Murphy's New Monsters Series as 'Horrible' and Full of 'Blatant Lies'

Published: Sep 23 2024

Erik Menéndez, a central figure in Netflix's gripping docudrama 'Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story,' has boldly spoken out about the latest series based on his life, voicing his profound discontent. On the fateful Friday, September 20th, Erik, through his brother Lyle's Facebook page, unleashed a scathing statement directed at Ryan Murphy's latest creation, lambasting the portrayal of both him and Lyle, now 56, who maintain they were victims of parental abuse and acted in self-defense when they took their parents' lives.

Erik Menéndez Slams Ryan Murphy's New Monsters Series as 'Horrible' and Full of 'Blatant Lies' 1

Erik, aged 53, delved into the depths of their traumatic childhood, marred by violence and abuse, lamenting that the series fails to capture the grim reality of their experiences. "I had naively believed we had transcended the realm of deceitful caricatures and malicious character assassinations of Lyle," he began, his words heavy with disappointment. "Yet, here stands a grotesque misrepresentation, rooted in blatant falsehoods, crafted seemingly with malice aforethought. It saddens me deeply to think that Ryan Murphy could be so willfully ignorant of the truth, allowing inaccuracies to flourish without a trace of good intention."

Erik's words echoed with emotion as he recounted how Netflix's depiction of their tragic tale had not only failed to honor their painful truths but had also regressed, dragging them back to a time when societal biases against male victims of sexual abuse and rape trauma were rampant. "It is tragic to witness how one man's quest for sensationalism has undone decades of progress in shedding light on the hidden wounds of childhood," he lamented.

Erik further accused Murphy, 58, of weaving a narrative "laced with vile distortions and slanderous portrayals of Lyle and myself," questioning the necessity for such distortions. "Is the truth not sufficient? Let it stand on its own merits," he pleaded, his voice tinged with frustration. "How demoralizing it is to realize that a single individual with influence can undermine years of hard work aimed at illuminating the darkness of childhood trauma."

In closing, Erik expressed gratitude to those who have stood by him, offering a heartfelt thank you to his supporters. 'Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story,' now streaming on Netflix, chronicles the brothers' descent into tragedy, from the brutal murders of their parents, José and Mary Louse "Kitty" Menéndez, in August 1989, to their subsequent trial and life sentences at the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego. Nicholas Alexander Chavez and Cooper Koch bring Lyle and Erik to life on screen, while Javier Bardem and Chloë Sevigny portray their ill-fated parents.

View all