Abbott Elementary – Season 2 Episode 17

Published: Jun 27 2025

Often, the chasm between generations within Abbott Elementary stems from the ideological rift between seasoned educators and their younger counterparts. Yet, in an unexpected twist, Jacob finds himself on the wrong side of the divide, the older figure struggling to grasp the latest craze. I, too, can empathize with this quandary, perched precariously between the millennial and Gen Z eras. I may not be a quintessential '90s child, but I vividly recall being in my elementary classroom when the world changed on September 11th. While I'm acquainted with numerous millennial references, I still manage to maintain a cool, trendy aura, steadfastly avoiding the cheugy label. However, my age precludes me from wielding any influence over my eight-year-old nephew in this realm.

Abbott Elementary – Season 2 Episode 17 1

Jacob grapples with a similar epiphany when his students become enraptured by 'The Silly Sock Show,' a quirky program featuring a family of sock puppets conversing in an invented language comprising solely of "mimimimi" sounds. Bewildered, Jacob dismisses it as mere socks, whereas his students and the ever-trendy Mr. Johnson adore it.

Concurrently, 'The Silly Sock Show' captures the heart of Abbott Elementary. Meanwhile, Jacob orchestrates a visit from Mural Arts Philadelphia, aiming to collaborate with his students on a mural that embodies their legacy, given it's their final year. After much deliberation, Jacob's class decides to base their mural on 'The Silly Sock Show.' This revelation crushes Jacob, particularly after Janine mentions that her elementary school mural evokes nostalgic, albeit cheesy, memories—a SpongeBob adorned with a cape and durag, painted by her class.

Undeterred by this revelation, Jacob remains steadfast in his belief that the tastes of his youth hold greater dignity. He boasts to Melissa about 'Ed, Edd, n Eddy,' highlighting its depth, evidenced by dedicated subreddits. Melissa gently disabuses him of this notion, reminding him that the show centered around three friends and a plank of wood with a crudely painted face. She emphasizes the enduring power of nostalgia, but Jacob remains unconvinced, fearing his students will regret their choice. Melissa reassures him, stating that their role is to "honor their present while nurturing their future."

Despite guiding his students toward a new mural idea—a sycamore tree symbolizing the unity of diverse Philadelphia communities—Jacob ultimately relents, embracing 'The Silly Sock Show' theme to celebrate his students' current personalities. To ensure a timeless element, they transform the mural into a mosaic, with each tile uniquely decorated by a student, illustrating their visions for the future. This heartwarming gesture aligns perfectly with the Mural Arts Philadelphia representative's mission, empowering students as the driving force behind the art.

The entire saga transported me back to the days of my middle school years. I've previously recounted my experience at a performing-arts school, not quite a charter but one that demanded acceptance for enrollment. I lived through and witnessed firsthand the practice of selecting only the "cream of the crop" students. Nestled in an Akron neighborhood often labeled "the hood," my school paradoxically stood in stark contrast to its surroundings. While I grew up amidst those streets, many of my classmates hailed from affluent parts of town, their backyards adorned with lush lawns and sparkling pools. Like Addington, my school, despite its location in an underserved area, actively turned away local students who couldn't meet its stringent criteria. Moreover, those whose parents possessed financial means could afford dance classes, instruments, art materials, and all manner of advantages for their offspring.

Kristin's revelation to her sister about Abbott potentially transforming into a charter school prompted Melissa to align with Barbara and eventually Ava to thwart this transition. Melissa discovered an online petition initiated by Abbott parents advocating for the school's inclusion in the Legendary Charter system. Melissa and Barbara vehemently opposed this notion, pointing out that Legendary didn't mandate teacher certification and that funds from wealthy benefactors with hidden agendas could compromise educational integrity. They feared losing autonomy over lesson planning, forced to adhere rigidly to Legendary's prescribed curricula. Most crucially, not all Abbott students would gain admission. Initially indifferent, Ava wasn't averse to reduced workload and increased financial inflow. However, a parent's account of her son being expelled from Addington due to poor test scores swayed Ava. Declaring her intent to exploit the school system if anyone would, she joined forces with Melissa and Barbara in their battle.

Meanwhile, Janine grappled with tidying up her tangled dating life. Been there, done that, sister. The aftermath of the teachers' conference left an awkward tension between Janine and Gregory. Both agreed it was imperative to inform Maurice of the incident, and Janine resolved to end things with him, realizing the kiss with Gregory signaled a fundamental disconnect. They all convened at Bone Town (rest assured, it's a restaurant, and this is a family-friendly narrative) to deliver the news. To their surprise, Maurice took it in stride, reassured by Janine and Gregory's insistence that the kiss meant nothing. But when Janine announced her decision to break up regardless, he flew into a rage. Who in their senses would embark on a date with someone, invite the person they cheated with, dismiss it as inconsequential, and then dump their partner? As Erika remarked, Janine might be a dork, but her messiness knows no bounds. And we cherish her for it.

View all