Episode 1 of "Nobody Wants This" kicks off with Joanne, fresh from a disastrous date, nursing her wounds. Fast-forward 119 episodes, and Joanne's relentless critiques of every suitor she's encountered have transformed her podcast, co-hosted with her sister Morgan, into a sensation. As James, a potential investor, calls late that night with an offer to take their show to the next level, Joanne and Morgan are overjoyed, sensing the cusp of greatness.
Amidst the turmoil of her parents' marriage disintegrating due to her father's coming out, Joanne finds solace and a push forward from her friend and business partner, Ashley, who invites her to a glitzy soirée.
Meanwhile, a glaring warning sign illuminates in the form of Rebecca, who invades the privacy of her boyfriend Noah by stealing an engagement ring he's been holding onto. Her audacity even extends to discussing marriage plans with his mother, prompting Noah to call it quits, wisely extricating himself from a potentially explosive situation.
Noah's heart swiftly rebounds as he crosses paths with Joanne at Ashley's bash. Their instant connection sparks amidst Ashley's playful meddling, their banter witty and their chemistry undeniable. Joanne is undeniably smitten, while Noah, having binge-listened to Joanne's podcast, finds himself preoccupied by her voice even when apart.
Ashley, the cunning matchmaker, sends a message to Joanne, informing her that Noah has inquired about her. Overwhelmed with excitement, Joanne attends Noah's first sermon, eager to catch a glimpse of him in his element.
Noah delivers a passionate sermon, but he's surrounded by a swarm of women vying for his attention, each hoping to pair him with their daughters. Yet, Noah's eyes are set on Joanne. As they converse afterward, sparks fly, but the disapproving glare from Noah's mother hints at potential obstacles to come.
