The second episode of "Sexy Beast" kicks off with a deeper dive into the McGraw gang's world and their intriguing connection to the mysterious coin. Gal, with Aitch lending a hand, grapples with cracking the safe they've recently stolen, under the looming deadline imposed by Teddy – just two weeks to pull it off. Teddy places his trust in Gal's ability to solve the puzzle, but Gal himself harbors doubts about its feasibility.
Meanwhile, Don asserts his unwavering loyalty to Gal, sparking a heated debate about their latest business venture. A targeted strike rocks McGraw's turf, prompting a stern warning from the local powerbroker. McGraw finds himself on a tightrope, with a daunting task to recover a missing, invaluable coin, and dire consequences looming if he fails.
Teddy Bass turns to Stan Higgins for insights on Freddy McGraw. Over at the boxing club, Gal's fiancée invites Don to join them on a double date, pairing him with one of her friends. He accepts, and the team delves into the intricacies of their safe-cracking mission, the pressure to succeed almost palpable. An associate dismissively mutters, "Don't bother," but failure is simply not an option for them.
Aitch's optimism wanes as he contemplates the high stakes they're playing with. The group engages in a heated discussion, pondering whether the heist is even doable. Gal, however, stands firm, reminding them of their pact with Teddy Bass and reassuring Aitch that they'll come through unscathed.
Later, at the Golden Eagle pub, Gal confides in his sister, Ann Marie, about her troubles, with their mother mistakenly believing it's due to a romantic entanglement.
The double date undergoes an unforeseen twist, as Don's wild antics turn the entire evening into a shambles. Gal's fiancée, utterly disgusted by Don's absurd behavior, declares emphatically that she doesn't want him at their wedding. Yet, Gal stands unwaveringly by his friend's side, pledging his unwavering loyalty and attributing Don's conduct to a troubled past that shadows his present.
Gal seeks an opportune moment to visit Dee Dee, and their emotions culminate in a passionate kiss. But their rendezvous takes a dark turn when Dee Dee's boyfriend arrives, brandishing a knife in a fit of jealousy. Gal, defending himself, engages in a fierce altercation and flees the scene.
Returning home, Gal faces inquisitive glances from his fiancée, who demands to know his whereabouts. Their conversation, however, takes a sudden turn as they find solace in an impromptu sexual encounter in the kitchen—perhaps a substitute for the affection Gal couldn't obtain from Dee Dee.
A plan to crack the safe begins to form in Gal's mind. But before executing it, Gal and Don visit Larry's place, where they're startled to find Ann Marie waiting. She demands to know Larry's whereabouts, and Gal, caught off guard, lies that Larry has left town for Ireland.
Elsewhere, Teddy Bass and Freddie McGraw face off at McGraw's club, though no immediate violence erupts—yet. Gal and Don eventually succeed in opening the safe, but instead of finding money, they discover a bizarre ornament that poses more questions than answers.
The episode concludes on a chilling note as Freddie McGraw indulges in a passionate kiss with a woman in a secluded area of his club. Just when the moment seems intimate and private, Teddy interrupts, attacking Freddie and violently raping him, leaving a grim and disturbing aftermath.
