The tenth episode of "The Rainmaker" opens with Bruiser discovering that Melvin is being held hostage in the basement of Prince's bar. She urgently requests Rudy to transfer Melvin to Detective Portillo's custody. As the story unfolds, we witness a tense negotiation between Deck and the detective, who eventually agrees to offer Melvin a plea bargain.
Rudy seizes the opportunity to use his 30 minutes of one-on-one time with Melvin to persuade him to plead guilty, with the aim of punishing the real culprit behind his mother's death – Great Benefit. Meanwhile, Drummond informs Sarah of Rudy's plan to convince her to withdraw from the case. Sarah, however, presses Drummond on the hospital cover-up, reminding him that truth is not their client's responsibility but rather their duty to defend their client, regardless of the truth.
The Federal agents question Brad about his involvement in crimes linked to Tinley Britt and his connection with Jane Allen. They offer Brad a deal – work with them to save himself from the consequences.
On the day of the hearing, Rudy presents Melvin Pritcher in court, causing Mr. Keeley to feel petrified. Melvin takes the stand and confesses to the murder of 15 patients at the hospital, including Donny Ray, bringing a sense of redemption to Mrs. Black. He also confesses to other crimes he committed.
Rudy brings up the arson that killed Melvin's mother, but Melvin denies any involvement in starting the fire. Drummond repeatedly attempts to object, but the judge overrules all objections. Melvin then confesses that Jane Allen, a woman working for Tinley Britt, tried to kill him. Drummond interrupts the interrogation and demands evidence.
During the cross-examination, Drummond relentlessly badgers Melvin, causing him to become increasingly aggressive and charge at Drummond. The scene is filled with tension and drama, as each character's actions and words play out in a high-stakes legal battle.
Rudy's approach to Sarah during recess is a delicate dance of subtle persuasion. As he tries to convince her to walk away while she still has the chance, Sarah stands firm, refusing to budge. Rudy's heart sinks as he realizes the person he once knew is no longer the same.
Meanwhile, Mrs. Black expresses her gratitude to Rudy for entrusting her with the truth. On the other hand, Brad attempts to elicit a confession from Drummond through a wire taped to his chest, but Drummond, being the seasoned professional he is, refuses to play along.
In court, Mr. Keeley hesitates to testify, but Sarah encourages him with a steadfast gaze. Mr. Keeley then asks Drummond to allow Sarah to handle his cross-examination, a gesture that suggests a growing trust between them.
During Mr. Keeley's interrogation, Rudy delves into the depths of his investigation, trying to coax the businessman into admitting to deleting the NarPense data to cover up the murders. Deck introduces Butch as a fake NarPense executive, and Mr. Keeley panics, confessing that he was the only person with the machine's code.
Sarah, during her cross-examination, attempts to have Mr. Keeley retract his confession by claiming that employees at Tinley Britt also had access to the NarPense code. Mr. Keeley counters with the revelation that Brad handled his records at Tinley Britt and was the only other person with access to the code.
As for Drummond's interrogation, Rudy informs Deck and Bruiser of his plan to put Leo on the stand. During the interrogation, Rudy weaves a web of connections, linking cases such as Rosalie Sutton's murder to Tinley Britt. He brings up the hiring of Jane Allen, but Drummond denies any responsibility, insisting that neither he nor Great Benefit had anything to do with Jane Allen's actions, even if she worked for Tinley Britt.
During the lunch break, Rudy whispers a request to Bruiser to take a step back. When they return to session, the judge informs Drummond that he can no longer serve as counsel for Great Benefit after becoming a witness on the stand. The moment is charged with the weight of legal and moral implications, setting the stage for further twists and turns in the investigation.
The stage is set for the closing arguments, where Rudy's appeal to the jury transcends mere words, transforming into a heartfelt plea for empathy towards the mother who lost her son. In stark contrast, Sarah's closing statement paints a picture of Rudy as someone who takes everything to heart, using his brother's death as a tool to divert attention from Great Benefit's involvement in Donny Ray's tragic end. She masterfully weaves a narrative that undermines any direct connection between Mr. Keeley and Donny's fate.
As the jury deliberates, Rudy finds solace in his return to the bar, reminiscing about his initial encounter with Sarah. The verdict is announced, and the jury's decision echoes through the room: Great Benefit is held liable for concealing the murder of Donny Ray. As compensation, Mrs. Black is awarded $1.5 million, and an additional $80.5 million in punitive damages, bringing the total to an astonishing $82 million.
Rudy and his team celebrate their victory, while the FBI's call to Drummond sets the stage for a new chapter. Brad's arrest shines a light on the consequences of their actions, while Drummond's revelation about Tinley Britt losing their tenth client after Mr. Keeley's involvement adds depth to the drama.
The season finale paints a triumphant picture, with Bruiser, Mrs. Black, Deck, and Rudy celebrating their success. Rudy reveals his decision to purchase Prince's bar, entrusting Butch with its management and offering Mrs. Black the prestigious position of head chef. Deck shares his contemplation of retaking the bar exam, symbolizing a new beginning for himself. The episode ends with Rudy passing the coin left behind by his brother to Deck, a poignant gesture that encapsulates the show's themes of inheritance and passing on legacy.
The epilogue adds a poignant touch, as Melvin and Brad are seen sharing a prison facility, their fates intertwined in a cycle of justice and retribution that mirrors the complexities of their respective journeys.
