At Hartford's 90s Con, the actor enthusiastically yet nervously conveyed his sentiments about reprising his role in the renowned horror franchise. Speaking at a panel, Lillard exclaimed, "Needless to say, I'm tight-lipped about the details. However, the prospect of returning fills me with immense excitement, tempered by a twinge of dread. The pressure is real; I could potentially tarnish the cherished legacy we've all built." He continued, "There's always the risk of disappointment—that I might fall short and inadvertently mar something untouchable that once stood untarnished. My deepest fear is that my return could somehow detract from its magic, leaving everyone underwhelmed. I sincerely hope I don't let anyone down."
In the original 1996 film, Lillard portrayed Stu Macher, a prominent antagonist alongside Billy Loomis (played by Skeet Ulrich). This pivotal role in Scream jumpstarted the actor's career, paving the way for numerous film and television appearances since then.
Scheduled for release on February 27, 2025, the seventh installment of Scream promises a blend of returning legends such as Neve Campbell and Courteney Cox, alongside fresh faces.