The gripping narrative of "American Rust: Broken Justice" Season 2, Episode 3 kicks off with Steve Park sequestered in his dimly lit basement, his gaze fixated on his eerie crime scene diorama, meticulously piecing together the fragments of a sinister puzzle. As Harris and Burgos delve into their investigation, they confront the professor embroiled in an illicit affair with Lily McKenna, grilling her on any prior encounters with Liam, the tragic victim of a heinous crime. She professes her familiarity with his name, yet their paths never crossed in person.
Meanwhile, at a politically charged event, District Attorney Sue Herlitz stands at the podium, delivering a speech amidst the looming election battle, her rival's presence adding an extra layer of tension. Grace, a bold voice amidst the crowd, rises to her feet, fearlessly voicing her discontent with Herlitz's perceived lack of empathy for the afflicted, citing her harsh treatment of Billy as proof.
After the grueling day's work, Harris and Burgos unwind over drinks at a local bar, the atmosphere charged with camaraderie. Burgos probes Harris's past, inquiring about his reasons for leaving Pittsburgh. He divulges a hint of philosophical turmoil, revealing a period of existential contemplation. Their conversation drifts to Vic Walker, a complex character Harris deems a capable officer marred by alcoholism. Burgos divulges a darker side, revealing Vic's history of domestic violence towards Cynthia, shocking Harris with the revelation.
Elsewhere, Sue Herlitz uncharacteristically abandons her reserved demeanor, indulging in heavy drinking and a bout of racy karaoke at a seedy bar. Her reckless night takes a tragic turn as she stumbles out, driving home inebriated. Her journey ends abruptly when a police cruiser pulls her over, its anonymous occupant emerging from the shadows, a fateful bullet piercing her skull through the window. The morning after, Steve Park, stumbling upon the grisly scene, discovers Herlitz's lifeless body, a grim testament to the twisted justice that plagues their town.
Billy perseveres with his rehabilitation journey, encountering an awkward encounter with Isaac as he lends a helping hand, only to stumble upon an unexpected arousal. Isaac, in an attempt to alleviate the tension, assures Billy that such occurrences are not uncommon, yet the air between them thickens with unspoken sentiments. Meanwhile, Harris extends an invitation to Vic, offering the warmth of his cabin in Buell for a cigar-filled evening and an overnight stay, which Vic eagerly embraces.
As Harris and Burgos confront Lily McKenna, her initial attempt at evasion is thwarted as they escort her for interrogation. Lily remains steadfast in her professed innocence, unwavering in her denial.
Grace, an intricate part of the undercover operation, prepares a culinary masterpiece for Harris and Vic, her culinary skills a testament to her dedication. However, a crucial mishap occurs when Vic inadvertently misplaces the lighter containing the vital bug. Grace, determined to rectify the situation, stealthily attempts to replant the device on Vic while he slumbers, her actions a testament to her cunning and resourcefulness.
Elsewhere, Isaac and Russell's bond transcends mere fling status as they share beers and deep conversations, delving into the intricacies of their respective families. Their connection deepens, forging a bond that extends beyond casual encounters.
Later, Billy, in the throes of sleepwalking, inadvertently approaches Lee, armed with the very murder weapon that sparked the events of season one, a weapon that Isaac had chosen to retain. Isaac, quick-witted, intervenes, pulling Billy away from potential catastrophe, as Billy slowly emerges from his psychotic state.
The episode concludes with a jarring revelation for Steve Park: a video depicting Grace attacking Sue Berlitz following their discussion regarding Billy's compensation. This damning footage fuels Steve's suspicion, casting a dark shadow over Grace and planting seeds of doubt in his mind that she might be entwined in Sue's murder.
