Episode 4 of "Bad Monkey" kicks off with a confrontational scene between Caitlin and Eve, igniting a web of intrigue that unravels a five-year-old mystery: How did Nick survive? The narrative rewinds, painting a vivid backdrop.
Eve, a novice actress with a solitary car commercial to her credit, finds herself on stage, but her talent falls short. Her tantrum against the director's constructive feedback costs her the lead in "Ghost," setting the stage for a twist in fate.
Meanwhile, Caitlin shares a close bond with her father, Nick, as she blossoms in magazine shoots. Yet, Nick's reluctance to let her attend launch parties clashes with Caitlin's teenage yearning for independence. At seventeen, she's eager to forge her own path.
But fate takes an unexpected turn when Nick, in a moment of vulnerability, catches sight of Eve. Their encounter blossoms into a forbidden romance, culminating in a shocking wedding where Caitlin's beloved dog is chosen as a bridesmaid over her, deepening the rift between them.
Elsewhere, Yancy, a cop in the Miami PD, finds himself embroiled in a rivalry with the corrupt Mendez. Yancy's integrity leads him to expose Mendez's dirty deeds, but the department's reluctance to air their laundry in public sees Mendez sidelined from the tip line and denied a promotion. As for Yancy, he's reassigned to the remote Keys.
Parallel to this, Nick and Izzy embark on the golden era of their Super Rollie scam, with Eve slyly insinuating herself into the operation. She fuels Nick's ambition, and the money flows like a river. Celebrations ensue, taking them to the idyllic Andros. Eve captivates Nick with visions of a luxurious resort, and he falls prey to her seduction. Neville, sensing danger, voices his concerns, but Nick is blinded by greed.
Just as Nick teeters on the brink of disaster, he realizes the need to flee. Eve, however, is unwilling to relinquish the lavish lifestyle, and Nick's love for her clouds his judgment. In a moment of weakness, he lets his desires overrule his sense of reason.
Meanwhile, Yancy and Bonnie's bond strengthens amidst turbulence. Bonnie's bruised eye, a testament to Cliff's brutality, serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of their impulsive decisions. These fateful choices, both Yancy's retaliation against Cliff and Nick's framing of a murder, cast long shadows over their lives, haunting them for years to come.
Before embarking on the drastic plan to amputate his arm and stage his own demise, Nick makes a heartfelt phone call to Caitlin. In a voice laced with regret, he offers an apology, acutely aware that his actions have irrevocably tangled their relationship. The irony is poignant; where he once feared Caitlin would flee with another, it was he who succumbed to Eve's seductive charms.
Izzy O'Peele, the unsung hero of this sordid affair, orchestrates the dark deeds. He hands over the ransom to Phinney and meticulously arranges the fake severed arm aboard the boat, even smashing it to pieces in the shower to account for the bone fragments discovered later. Meanwhile, Eve's emotional numbness, foreshadowed early on, becomes her downfall when Yancy meticulously pieces together the truth.
Nick's path unexpectedly crosses with the formidable Dragon Queen and Ya-Ya, igniting a tempest of drama. Yet, Phinney's greed remains insatiable, relentlessly extorting Nick for more money. Eve, on the other hand, toys with the idea of ending Phinney's life, confessing to the hit-and-run incident with chilling calmness.
Izzy, struggling to cope, finds himself visited by Yancy, followed by Nick's ominous arrival. Nick's anger boils over when he learns of Izzy's intention to expose the truth. In a desperate bid to cover his tracks, Nick makes the heinous choice to silence his friend, forever.
Tragedy strikes when, in the midst of Nick's impassioned confession of his sacrifices for their sake in the deserted parking lot, Heather from the Weather Channel happens upon the scene. Eve, without hesitation, intercedes, her actions swift and fatal. Nick, left with no other option, conceals Heather's lifeless body in the trunk of her car, sealing their dark secret within.
This brings us to the present moment, where Madeline stands unscathed, her life spared from the clutches of death. However, the tragic news of Heather's demise ripples through the media, casting a somber shadow. Nick, striving for redemption, endeavors to mend his frayed relationship with Caitlin, offering heartfelt apologies for his shortcomings as a father in recent times. He vows to be her rock, standing by her side whenever she calls.
Meanwhile, Yancy's relentless pursuit of Caitlin's attention intertwines with Rosa's determination to unravel the mystery behind Izzy's death. Together, they delve deeper, skeptical of Mendez's conclusion of a murder-suicide, convinced that foul play is at hand. Their shared quest for the truth fosters an intimacy that culminates in a passionate encounter.
Elsewhere, Eve dangles a sinister proposition before Nick—the thought of harming Caitlin. Nick's indignation boils over as he confronts her, yet Eve's unexpected tears disarm him, weaving a web of confusion and leaving him questioning his own perceptions. Just as this emotional turmoil unfolds, a witness emerges from the shadows, whispering to Mendez of a sighting: Yancy leaving Izzy's apartment, casting a fresh shadow of suspicion.
That very night, inspiration strikes Yancy, prompting him to reach out to Rosa. A realization dawns—Nick and Christopher are but facets of the same enigmatic figure, and the so-called murder was but a ruse. His revelation hangs heavy in the air, until Nick's sudden appearance shatters the silence. With a tire iron clenched in his fist, Nick's anger unleashes in a brutal blow, leaving Yancy stunned and the truth hanging precariously in the balance.
