Episode 10 of "Nobody Wants This" kicks off with a flurry of anticipation as Noah and Joanne meticulously prepare for the upcoming bat mitzvah. However, beneath the surface of her bustling preparations, Joanne harbors a secret anxiety - a feigned illness that threatens to upend her attendance. She nurses a lingering fear, convinced that Bina's petty curse from the previous episode's climax could be the tipping point. Yet, she keeps her doubts to herself, unwilling to burden Noah with her superstitions.
Amidst this turmoil, Joanne turns to her circle of friends for solace, her mind churning with questions about her own identity and the pull of Judaism. Meanwhile, Sasha's voice of reason pierces through Noah's enthusiastic discourse on conversion, gently cautioning him that his zeal is scaring her away.
Sasha's words inadvertently touch upon the tangled web of Rebecca and Morgan's drama, and she ultimately finds herself compelled to set the record straight with Morgan as well. Joanne, realizing her initial judgment may have been misguided, is compelled to issue a heartfelt apology to her tumultuous sister, even though the roots of the mess lie solely with Morgan's impulsive confession.
As the sisters reconcile, they forge a mischievous plan, determined to steal the spotlight at the bat mitzvah. In a flurry of outlandish outfits, they crash the celebration, transforming it into a spectacle all their own, oblivious to the fact that it's Miriam's day to shine. The chaos they unleash underscores their unwavering bond, even as they inadvertently steal the thunder from the rightful protagonist of the evening.
Joanne, with renewed conviction, boldly declares her intention to embrace Noah's world and even embraces the idea of conversion with genuine joy. Meanwhile, Morgan confronts Rebecca, accusing her of meddling in Joanne and Noah's relationship. In the heat of the moment, Sasha's name is dragged into the fray, inadvertently causing Esther's world to crumble as she stumbles upon the realization that Sasha has been confiding in Morgan.
Esther scrutinizes the messages exchanged between Sasha and Morgan, finding nothing incriminating but, juxtaposed with Bina's situation, she decides it's time for the sisters to depart. As fate would have it, Esther discovers Miriam in the bathroom, viciously tearing apart her gown, confessing its hideousness. In a turn of events, they bond over their shared plight, collaborating to salvage their outfits and forge a deeper connection.
Following Noah's impassioned speech, Rebecca storms off, only to be pursued by Joanne, who engages her in a heart-to-heart. Joanne confesses her long-held infatuation, and to her surprise, discovers that Rebecca harbors similar sentiments. However, Rebecca's revelation about the weight of responsibility that comes with conversion—not just embracing Judaism but being a beacon of inspiration—casts a shadow of doubt. The pressure of being a role model is immense.
Rebecca's lifelong aspiration of becoming Mrs. Head Rabbi now seems an unattainable dream, and Joanne is consumed by guilt. Unable to ignore her true feelings, Joanne confides in Noah, baring her soul: she does not wish to convert. While Judaism holds a profound beauty for her, she questions whether she is truly ready for such a monumental commitment. This honest admission leaves Noah unsure of Joanne's preparedness and the future of their burgeoning bond hangs in the balance.
Noah utters the heartfelt words, "I love you," and these three simple phrases embroil the situation in a web of complexities. In a decisive moment, Joanne chooses to sever ties with him, her footsteps echoing as she turns away, inadvertently leaving Morgan behind in the midst of their chaos.
As she strides towards the sanctuary of her home, Joanne's thoughts are heavy with emotions. But upon stepping off the bus, she's confronted with an unexpected sight—Noah, standing there, waiting for her with a resolve etched on his face. Realizing the impossibility of holding onto both, he's made a choice: he would rather cherish her presence than struggle with an impossible balance. The air between them crackles with the intensity of his decision, painting a poignant picture of love's sacrifices and the bittersweet reality of letting go.
