As the curtain rises on another chapter of Sullivan's Crossing, Sully (Scott Patterson) attempts to reach Lola (Amalia Williamson), only to leave a message imploring her to return his call. Maggie (Morgan Kohan) steps in, concern etched across her face as she checks on her father. Sully assures her he's alright, before dialing Frank's number, suggesting a stroll together. Edna (Andrea Menard) then beckons Frank (Tom Jackson) to the phone, and upon picking up, Frank declares his intention to visit Sully, stressing the importance of their sponsorship bond. Though Edna wonders how Frank can bear with Sully's shortcomings yet struggle with his own cousin, Frank reveals that Sully has confessed to Lola. Worried that Lola's trust may be irretrievably shattered, Sully seeks solace, to which Frank responds with a philosophical nod towards time's healing power.
Sully confesses to withholding the truth from Maggie, fearing it's not the opportune moment. He yearns for a resolution, acknowledging that confrontation with his past is inevitable. Meanwhile, Lola is trapped in a loop of the accident's haunting replay. Maggie, seeking a distraction, visits Cal (Chad Michael Murray), inquiring about Sedona's whereabouts. Cal informs her that Sedona has an appointment with the specialist Maggie recommended, and they share breakfast, where Maggie casually mentions her pregnancy. Their conversation veers towards the Crossing's investor – the golf course owner across the lake – and Maggie resolves to reorder her life. When Cal brings up Andrew, Maggie reveals their split, asserting they've mutually decided to part ways. As for Cal, he intends to volunteer with the Search and Rescue team until he decides his next career move.
At the restaurant, Jane (Cindy Sampson) greets Rob (Reid Price), their chat briefly veering into the realm of Rob's wife. Jane opens up about her divorce struggles, emphasizing the isolation that accompanied her silence. She finds solace in vulnerability, offering her ear to Rob regarding his late wife, Sarah. Maggie, on another call, consults Phoebe (Lynda Boyd) about interviewing nannies, though her heart isn't in it. Phoebe mentions Walter's heartbreak and their leniency in letting him keep his license as a form of redemption. The call concludes abruptly.
Elsewhere, Cal discusses his volunteering decision with Connie (Lauren Hammersley), who admits a fascination with starting anew somewhere unfamiliar. Cal counters that nothing binds her to her current path. Maggie returns home to find Sully, and he breaks down, insisting she deserves to know the truth: after the accident with Lola, he was inconsolable until Frank found him and steered him towards rehab. By then, the incident was framed as a hit-and-run. Sully believed he could better assist Lola from rehab than from a jail cell. He yearns for reassurance of her wellbeing, prompting Maggie to volunteer to check on Lola. She acknowledges Sully's driving was wrong but underscores their shared desperation to reunite that fateful day.
Frank and Edna delve into a deeper conversation about Sully, with Frank hinting at an impending revelation. Meanwhile, Jackson (T. Thomason)'s unexpected return surprises Connie, who hands over the house key. After his departure, Connie muses on parenting and the eventual necessity of letting go.
She readily acknowledges her gratitude towards Tom for convincing her to embark on the journey of parenthood. Maggie, concerned for Lola's wellbeing, visits her to ascertain her condition and endeavors to persuade Lola that Sully would never deliberately cause her harm. However, Lola rationalizes that she should feel relieved, given her past reluctance for Lola to be a part of Sully's life. Eventually, Maggie is requested to depart.
Edna comes to know about Sully's assault on Lola. Frank clarifies his initial silence, but Edna remains dissatisfied. Maggie informs Sully of the situation, suggesting that he should simply grant Lola some breathing space. In response, Sully entrusts Maggie with his mortgage documents, bank account details, and the deed to the Crossing, anticipating that she will need them during negotiations concerning Glenn's position at the Crossing. Contemplating turning himself in to the authorities, Sully expresses his desire to confront the consequences. Maggie urges him to contact Frank, yet she also requests permission to call Cal, a defense attorney. Meanwhile, Lola consumes pills in a moment of despair.
A nostalgic flashback reveals Sedona (Meghan Ory) inquiring if Lola has revisited the location of her trauma. Seeking solace, Lola decides to return to that haunting spot, hoping it might bring clarity. Returning to Frank, Edna reminds him of her unwavering support and voices her frustration at being overlooked. She confesses her weariness of always playing second fiddle. Frank assures her that he will return to fetch her before departing. Cal advises Maggie that Sully's fate hinges on Lola's decision to press charges, acknowledging the possibility of prison time for Sully. He underscores the significance of Sully's current efforts to do the right thing and offers to guide him through the impending procedures.
Lola revisits the scene of the accident. Maggie, unsuccessful in reaching Lola who has stepped out of her car, leaves a message updating her on the developments. Lola's fragmented memories of the accident gradually piece together, leading her to realize that it wasn't Sully who hit her at all.
Sully prepares to surrender himself at the police station until Lola interrupts him, asserting that another vehicle was involved. Sydney enters the restaurant, greeted warmly by Rob. She shares that her meeting was productive but decides against returning, believing she no longer belongs in that realm. She expresses her readiness to move forward with Rafe. Connie calls Noah to inquire about the job opportunity at Otter Lake. Maggie and Sully discuss their recent revelations, while Cal suggests that cross-referencing the vehicle description with speeding tickets might aid the investigation. Sully departs, and Maggie expresses her heartfelt thanks to Cal for his support, admitting she will deeply miss him. Cal bids farewell shortly after. Lola calls Maggie to apologize for her earlier rudeness and invites her over to discuss something important.
Sydney ventures to see Rafe (Dakota Taylor), her heart set on informing him of her decision to abandon the modeling world. She stands at the threshold of a new chapter, ready to embark on this journey with him. However, Rafe harbors doubts about their ability to seamlessly resume their previous connection. He fears that Sydney might not be emotionally prepared for the depths of a genuine relationship. With a heavy heart, Sydney departs.
At their home, Frank confesses to Edna that his bond with Sully has inadvertently overshadowed their own relationship, acknowledging his unfairness. As a token of his unwavering commitment, he presents her with his mother's regalia, recently reclaimed through the efforts of his cousin. Frank vows that she is the only one for him, pledging his eternal devotion.
Elsewhere, Lola confides in Maggie, revealing that for years, she blamed the person who caused her accident for all the adversity in her life. Now, she recognizes that Sully's deception stemmed from his fear of losing her. Lola hands Maggie the letter Cal left behind in his cabin, admitting she had kept it out of jealousy. Maggie understands Lola's motive, acknowledging her own envy towards her friend. As Maggie reads the letter, she discovers Cal's desire to leave his past behind and move forward. Lola reminds Maggie that Cal returned to Sullivan's Crossing solely for her, revisiting the moment Sedona revealed his love for her.
Lola then seeks out Sully for a heart-to-heart conversation, grasping the rationale behind his lies. Sully asserts that his love for her has always been genuine, unwavering. Meanwhile, Glenn calls Sully with a sudden reversal of his earlier decision, proposing an uneven profit split of 70-30. Sully, aware that this negotiation encompasses his future, reminds Glenn of its significance. Glenn retaliates with a threat, hinting at the possibility of Sully losing his establishment to a competitor at an auction. With a chill in his voice, Glenn expresses eagerness to bid against Sully.
After the call, Sully concedes that Frank's warnings about Glenn were justified, regretting his misplaced trust. Sully vows to fight tooth and nail, refusing to let their dreams be snatched away without a battle.
