As the curtain raises on the premiere episode of "The Four Seasons," Jack (portrayed by Will Forte) catches up with Kate (played by Tina Fey) just as the school bell chimes, signaling the end of the day. Inside Jack's car, Kate promptly dials Claude (Marco Calvani) and Danny (Colman Domingo), urging them to be at the ready. Danny's retort, reminding Kate she doesn't hold the reins as his boss, adds a spicy undertone to the conversation. Shortly thereafter, they pick up Danny and his spouse Claude, the ambiance in the vehicle charged with anticipation.
Kate then taps into her digital network, messaging Nick (Steve Carell) and Anne (Kerry Kenney) with their impending arrival time. Danny's casual mention of crawfish sets the stage for an evening feast. Kate's phone buzzes with a message from Nick Pagano, alerting them to peculiar creatures blocking the road ahead. Switching on her high beams, Kate's gaze falls upon Nick and Anne, stranded by the roadside. Nick jokes about how their tardiness had them resorting to premature revelry.
Once inside, the group dives into preparing the crawfish boil, with Kate's growling stomach prompting her to inquire about dinner's progress to Jack, who offers a less-than-optimistic outlook. Nick, creeping up behind them, playfully wonders about their hush-hush chatter.
At long last, dinner is served. Jack, seated beside Claude, engages him in conversation about his Napoleon tome. Jack raises a toast to Nick and Anne, celebrating their silver anniversary, lauding them as an epitome of inspiration. He proclaims that all six of them have conquered adversity to find their life partners. Kate, ever the skeptic, disputes the notion of soulmates, contending their enduring bonds stem from unwavering commitment. Danny counters that young love transcends rational control, suggesting their current harmony is a fruit of wisdom and shared experiences—a conscious choice they've all made.
The following day, Claude solicits a ride into town from Kate, but Jack's offer to chauffeur him piques Danny's interest in a hiking expedition instead. Anne expresses her desire to visit town, leading to a poignant moment as Nick strolls alongside Danny and Jack, querying if they are genuinely content. Nick then drops a bombshell, confessing his intentions to leave Anne due to years of unhappiness. He claims Anne remains oblivious, engrossed in her iPad farm game, while he's reached his breaking point after two and a half decades.
At the store, Anne confides in Kate about Nick's perception of her abandoning her ceramic aspirations. Meanwhile, Claude collects his medication, casually mentioning they are for his husband to the pharmacist (Jeff Brooks). Nick stands firm in his decision, unswayed by Jack's anecdote of overcoming a rough patch with Kate through yoga—a venture Jack initially loathed until they reconnected. Danny urges Nick to seek solace elsewhere temporarily, to no avail. Kate's curiosity leads her to inquire about Danny's prescription for vasodilators from Claude, who reveals Danny's recent struggles with dizziness and chest pains. Hospital visits and numerous tests later, they learned of a 70% blockage, necessitating a stent implantation scheduled for the upcoming week.
Later, they all converge, engaging in camaraderie and shared experiences. The conversation drifts towards exploring distant shores, and when the notion of securing travel tickets arises, Nick suggests they hold off until the horizon seems a tad nearer. Danny, who unveils his upcoming Miami business trip for next week, proposes an escapade on the boat instead. Anne declares her intention to cozy up with her blanket and observe from afar, but Danny persuasion prevails, urging her to join them. Jack casually mentions attending yoga sessions with Kate, to which she responds with bewilderment, insisting she's never set foot in The Breath Factory. Spontaneous as ever, Jack dives into the water, swimming towards the shore, with the others soon following suit. Kate's anxiety over Danny's heart condition surfaces, prompting him to admit he hesitated to share the news for fear of her concern. She eventually joins them, followed by Anne. Meanwhile, Jack and Danny catch a glimpse of Nick and Anne sharing a tender moment. Anne grapples to reboard the boat, with Nick encouraging her persistently until Claude lends a helping hand. That evening, nestled in bed, Anne plants a kiss on Nick, whispering "happy anniversary" before immersing herself in her farming game. Danny receives a message informing him of a marble delivery delay, obviating the need for his Miami trip this week. He responds with resolve, intending to visit regardless. Claude, frustrated by his inability to alter Danny's appointment through a digital portal, grows agitated and surrenders his efforts. He tentatively asks if he might stay home the following week, but Danny disingenuously asserts their Miami presence as crucial. Jack confides in Kate about Nick contemplating leaving Anne, expressing uncertainty on both their parts. Kate's mind drifts back to forgotten yoga classes with Jack, expressing a desire to reclaim those memories.
The morning unfolds with Danny rousing everyone, urging them downstairs posthaste. They discover Anne's elaborate anniversary surprise for Nick – a surprise vow renewal ceremony. Anne harbors trepidation, fearing his overwhelming reaction.
