Brooks Nader left no stone unturned during her recent late-night appearance, as the model and reality star not only captivated the crowd but also left a few viewers stunned with a candid confession. When asked by a fan to name a celebrity she had "completely turned down," Nader, 28, didn't hesitate to share the story with a mischievous grin.
Labeling the fan a "feisty little girl," Nader explained that rejecting the unnamed actor wasn't about ego but simply a matter of preference. "Maybe they were too old and ugly," she joked, hinting that the person in question had won multiple Oscars without revealing their identity. The implication sent host Andy Cohen and viewers into a frenzy, speculating which actor she might have been referring to.

Nader added a humorous family rule when discussing her romantic history, stating that her father has a long-standing request that she not marry anyone older than he is. "He's only 50," she said, laughing. "So I have to respect that in a way." The playful comments kept the moment light, even as online speculation brewed about the identity of the actor in question.
The conversation also touched on Nader's romantic history with her "Dancing With the Stars" partner, Gleb Savchenko. She confirmed that the two dated and even revealed they became intimate the first day they met, hours before their scheduled Good Morning America appearance.
Away from reality TV, Nader has been navigating major life changes. She and her ex-husband, Billy Haire, ended their nearly decade-long relationship in 2024. The two met when she was 19, and he was in his early thirties, eventually marrying in 2019 before announcing their divorce five years later. Nader has described the breakup as one of the hardest decisions she's made, but emphasized that it shaped who she is today. Haire has since moved on and gone public with "Southern Charm" star Naomie Olindo.