‘Mindhunter’ May Return as Three Movies, Star Holt McCallany Reveals

Published: Jun 20 2025

Hope sparkles anew for devoted "Mindhunter" enthusiasts. Holt McCallany, who co-starred in the gripping Netflix series for two seasons alongside Jonathan Groff, recently imparted some eagerly anticipated news to CBR regarding the potential revival of the show—potentially reimagined as a trilogy of feature-length films. In an intimate revelation, the "Waterfront" actor shared, "A few months back, I had a sit-down with David Fincher in his office, and he hinted at the possibility of it resurfacing as three two-hour movies. However, it's still very much up in the air."

‘Mindhunter’ May Return as Three Movies, Star Holt McCallany Reveals 1

McCallany further elaborated, painting a vivid picture of the behind-the-scenes process, "I'm aware that screenwriters are toiling away, but David's seal of approval is crucial. He's incredibly meticulous; it's what makes him, in my opinion, Hollywood's finest director," he said, donning his hat as a fan while promoting "The Iron Claw." "During our meeting, he bestowed upon me a glimmer of hope, but let's just say, it's contingent upon a perfect alignment of cosmic forces."

The psychological thriller, which premiered on Netflix in 2017 and 2019, delved into the minds of serial killers through the eyes of Bill (McCallany) and Holden (Groff). The streaming giant opted against a third season primarily due to exorbitant production costs, as Fincher once elaborated, stating, "It's an expensive endeavor, and unfortunately, we failed to garner an audience size that Netflix deemed worthy of such an investment."

Nonetheless, as six years have slipped by, the avid followers of "Mindhunter" have never ceased their yearning for a sequel. As early as 2021, Groff, in an interview with The Hollywood Reporter, articulated his desire to return, his enthusiasm brimming as he spoke of the joy of collaborating with Fincher: "'Mindhunter,' to me, is Fincher. Working alongside him was an immense honor. That's what drew me in at the core." Groff's emotions flowed sincerely, "At his beck and call, I would join without hesitation. Yet, I place complete trust in his vision and instincts; thus, the decision has always rested solely in his hands, as it always has."

View all