The eleventh episode of "The Judge from Hell" kicks off with a dramatic rescue by Arong, who arrives at the eleventh hour to thwart a fatal stabbing attempt on Daon. Bitna, swift and decisive, conjures her blade and efficiently dispatches Paimon, sending his soul back to the depths of Hell. Yet, curiously, this feat does not add to her tally of kills; perhaps, the rules of this realm are more nuanced.
As Mando and the Hell clean-up crew arrive on the scene, Bitna retaliates against Arong, now revealed to be Venato but affectionately still called Arong, with a series of forceful slaps. Arong, with a stern warning, cautions Bitna that her closeness to Daon could lead to her untimely demise.
Bitna then ventures to the abandoned lot, specifically targeting the pentagram inscribed upon it. Bael makes his grand entrance, lambasting Justitia for her impulsive actions and conjuring her Hellish blade. Demonstrating his formidable powers, reminiscent of episode one, he decrees that Justitia shall remain on Earth as a mere mortal, stripped of her celestial abilities. In an instant, he redefines her identity, erasing her as Justitia.
Back at the station, Daon navigates a tense interrogation with officers, weaving a web of lies to extricate himself from trouble. Returning home, Bitna confides in Daon that Jeong Seonho is not J, her conclusion drawn from their conversation. Despite her loss of powers, Bitna vows to stand by Daon's side, albeit the path ahead is fraught with uncertainty.
Determined to forge a new strategy, Bitna visits the Assemblyman and announces her intention to marry into the family. With a twist, she declares her desire to wed Seonho, not Taegyu, much to Jaegeol's amusement and intrigue. Bitna's keen observation catches Seonho entering a hidden room in the study, a detail she mentally files away.
As night falls, Taegyu confronts his father about Bitna, and Jaegeol ponders her potential utility, though the air between father and son is thick with tension.
Meanwhile, at the station, the frost between Eunseop and Daon remains unbroken, despite Daon's efforts to apologize. However, they share a meal together, where the conversation veers towards Bitna's stabbing. Eunseop confesses his suspicions about the Jung family's involvement in her demise.
The narrative then pivots to Soyeong, as Eunseop and Daon finally confront their emotions. Eunseop is consumed by guilt, while Daon attempts to lighten the mood with a playful joke, suggesting Eunseop foot the dinner bill as a token of his repentance.
After the two had mended their differences, Eunseop provided Daon with a pivotal piece of information: he was to meet with Professor Lee Jihye at Yeonseon Hospital. This was the very woman who had treated Bitna following her near-fatal stabbing. Myeongsook, torn between emotions as Serial Killer J reappeared, found herself sobbing inconsolably in the church, feeling betrayed after twenty years of prayerful hope for redemption. As she exited the church, her legs gave out, collapsing just as Bitna appeared on the scene. Bitna assisted Myeongsook back to her home, where the pattering of raindrops outside stirred her memory.
Myeongsook recounted the chilling encounter of a man clutching a white rose, escaping just after committing the murder of her son. Despite her valiant effort to grapple with him, he slipped away, leaving her desperate for justice. Initially, she harbored a hope to understand and perhaps forgive him, but her frustration and anger soon overshadowed these feelings. Ultimately, she pleaded with Bitna to help track him down and ensure that justice was served.
Bitna made her way to the Assemblyman's residence. Finding Taegyu and Jaegeol out golfing, she seized the opportunity to explore the hidden room. Inside, she discovered an ornate chamber, clearly a significant clue. The photograph served as a portal, and as she stepped through, she unlocked a vault revealing an axe and a grotesque collection of body parts preserved on ice.
In her haste to leave, Bitna ran straight into Seonho, who swung a bat at her. The pair exchanged blows, culminating in Bitna being knocked unconscious. When she awoke, Seonho revealed the truth behind the incident in December 2023 when the real Bitna was stabbed in the park. Bitna had stumbled upon the hidden room, where Taegyu's torture of his mother was recorded on video. Taegyu, noticing her intrusion, instructed Seonho to attack her. Compelled by his brother's order, Seonho was the one who inflicted the wound, leaving Bitna to bleed out.
Bitna attempted to negotiate with Seonho, indirectly proposing to eliminate Taegyu. Their altercation continued until Arong met with Daon, handing over blueprints of Jeong's residence that she had initially stolen. She urged him to use them to save Bitna before it was too late. Daon rushed into the mansion, found the bookshelf, pulled the correct book, and subdued Seonho. Bitna prevented Daon from killing him, and as he assisted her, Seonho slipped away. Daon embraced Bitna, as she indicated that the true Satan and J were either Taegyu or Jaegeol, though she was uncertain which.
Bitna and Daon left the mansion, with Bitna heading to confront Bael once more. She confessed to Bael that she had discovered Satan and sought her powers back to confront him definitively. Given that Justitia was his sole heir, he warned her, and she vowed not to disappoint. And thus, he restored her powers.
Seonho sought refuge in a motel, where Bitna eventually found him. She led him to an isolated location, set his car aflame, and watched it explode into the night sky. Yet, she refrained from sending him to Hell with her blade, for reasons known only to her.
